Chiropractor Vs Physiotherapist for Hip Pain: Which to Choose?

Chiropractor or Physiotherapist for Hip Pain? How to Decide in Gqeberha
Hip pain can be surprisingly difficult to understand.
You might feel it when getting out of the car, walking upstairs, going for a run or simply lying on your side at night.
Sometimes it feels like a deep ache in the groin. Other times, it's on the outside of the hip or somewhere around the buttock.
And when it doesn't settle, a common question is:
Should I see a chiropractor or a physiotherapist for my hip pain?
Both professions help people with musculoskeletal problems, including hip pain. Both may use hands-on treatment, exercise and movement advice.
The more important question is what might be causing your pain and what type of care is appropriate for your particular situation.
Let's look at how to make that decision.
Understanding Where Your Hip Pain Is Coming From
One of the first things I consider when assessing someone with hip pain is exactly where they feel it.
That doesn't give us a diagnosis on its own, but it can provide useful clues.
1. Pain in the Front of the Hip or Groin
Pain deep in the groin or front of the hip may involve the hip joint itself.
Possible causes include:
Hip osteoarthritis
Irritation of structures within the joint
Hip flexor tendon problems
Femoroacetabular impingement-related pain
Other conditions affecting the hip or surrounding tissues
People sometimes describe a catching sensation or difficulty putting on shoes and socks.
They may also notice discomfort when sitting in a low chair, getting into a car or rotating the hip.
These symptoms deserve a proper examination rather than an assumption that the joint is simply stiff or out of alignment.
2. Pain on the Outside of the Hip
Pain on the outer side of the hip is another common presentation.
It may be particularly noticeable when:
Lying on the affected side
Walking uphill or climbing stairs
Standing on one leg
Running or increasing walking distance
Getting up after sitting for a while
One possible explanation is greater trochanteric pain syndrome, which often involves irritation or reduced load tolerance of the gluteal tendons.
Treatment frequently involves modifying aggravating activities and gradually improving the capacity of the muscles and tendons around the hip.
Simply stretching the area isn't always helpful and can sometimes aggravate symptoms.
3. Pain in the Buttock or Back of the Hip
Pain around the buttock can be more complicated.
It may originate from local muscles or tendons, the hip joint, the sacroiliac region or the lower back.
Sometimes, irritation of nerves in the lumbar spine can contribute to pain felt around the hip or down the leg.
This is why examining only the painful area may not provide the full picture.
For more information, I've written about the relationship between hip pain and lower back pain.
Can Hip Pain Actually Come From Your Lower Back?
Yes.
And it's one of the reasons a thorough assessment matters.
The lower back and hip work together during everyday activities such as walking, bending and getting up from a chair.
Certain lower-back conditions can cause referred pain into the buttock, outer hip or thigh.
Sometimes there is little noticeable back pain.
Other clues that the lumbar spine may be contributing include:
Pain that changes with certain back movements
Symptoms extending below the knee
Tingling or numbness
Pain associated with prolonged sitting
Weakness or other neurological symptoms
These findings don't automatically mean the spine is responsible, but they help guide the examination.
A good clinician should consider both the hip and the lumbar spine rather than assuming the problem must originate where the pain is felt.
How Can a Chiropractor Help With Hip Pain?
Chiropractors are trained to assess and manage musculoskeletal conditions involving the spine and other joints.
At my practice in Walmer, Gqeberha, I begin by trying to understand the nature of the problem.
Depending on the symptoms, this may involve assessing:
Hip range of motion
Lumbar spine movement
Muscle strength and function
Relevant orthopaedic tests
Neurological function where indicated
Walking and other movements that reproduce symptoms
The examination helps determine whether chiropractic treatment is appropriate or whether another approach or referral would be more useful.
Chiropractic Treatment Options
Depending on the findings, treatment may include:
Joint mobilisation or manipulation
Hands-on techniques may help improve movement and provide short-term relief for certain musculoskeletal problems.
Soft tissue treatment
Treatment of muscles and surrounding tissues may help with pain and movement tolerance in selected cases.
Exercise and rehabilitation
Specific exercises can help improve strength, movement confidence and tolerance for daily activities.
Activity advice
Sometimes, changing how much or how often you perform an aggravating activity is an important part of recovery.
Chiropractic treatment doesn't necessarily mean that every patient requires a spinal adjustment.
The treatment should follow the assessment, not the other way around.
How Can a Physiotherapist Help With Hip Pain?
Physiotherapists also assess and manage a wide range of hip and lower-limb conditions.
Their treatment may include:
Progressive strengthening
Exercise rehabilitation
Movement retraining
Manual therapy
Advice on activity modification
Return-to-sport programmes
Education about pain and recovery
For example, someone with gluteal tendinopathy may benefit from a progressive strengthening programme that gradually increases the load their hip can tolerate.
Someone recovering from hip surgery may require a more structured rehabilitation programme.
Physiotherapy can be particularly valuable when a condition requires ongoing exercise progression, although many chiropractors also provide rehabilitation.
The two professions have considerable overlap.
Chiropractor vs Physiotherapist: What's the Difference for Hip Pain?
The distinction isn't as simple as saying chiropractors treat joints and physiotherapists treat muscles.
Both professions can assess movement, provide manual treatment, prescribe exercises and help patients manage musculoskeletal pain.
Individual practitioners may differ more in their experience, interests and treatment approach than their professional titles suggest.
Hip and lower-back assessment: Chiropractor: Yes, Physiotherapist: Yes
Joint mobilisation or manipulation: Chiropractor: Commonly used, Physiotherapist: May be used
Strengthening and rehabilitation: Chiropractor: May be provided, Physiotherapist: Commonly emphasised
Movement and activity advice: Chiropractor: Yes, Physiotherapist: Yes
Post-surgical rehabilitation: Chiropractor: Depends on practitioner and training, Physiotherapist: Common area of practice
Referral for medical investigation: Chiropractor: When indicated, Physiotherapist: When indicated
The right choice depends on the condition, the clinician's experience and whether their approach matches your needs.
You shouldn't need to choose between two professions based on the assumption that one treats the cause while the other only treats the symptoms.
Good care from either profession should aim to understand the problem, improve function and help you manage your recovery.
When Might You Benefit From Both Chiropractic and Physiotherapy?
Some patients benefit from care involving more than one healthcare professional.
For example, someone with persistent hip pain may benefit from hands-on treatment for symptom relief while also following a progressive rehabilitation programme.
But this doesn't mean manual treatment must always happen before strengthening.
In many cases, exercise and appropriate activity modification can begin early.
The decision to involve another practitioner should be based on the diagnosis, response to treatment and specific rehabilitation needs.
What matters is that the professionals involved communicate and work towards the same goals.
Why Hip Pain Sometimes Keeps Coming Back
One of the challenges with recurring hip pain is that symptoms can settle before someone has fully returned to their normal activities.
Imagine someone who develops hip pain after increasing their running distance.
They stop running for two weeks, and the pain improves.
Then they return immediately to their previous mileage, and the discomfort comes back.
That doesn't necessarily mean something has gone out of alignment or that the original treatment failed.
It may simply mean the hip hasn't yet regained the capacity to tolerate the demands being placed on it.
Other factors can includour specific response to initial treatment.




Comments